
On her blog this week, author Jessica Verday, writer of the popular Young Adult The Hollow Trilogy
, told the story of why she rejected the offer to be a part of the Wicked Pretty Things anthology. To put it simply? Her short story was too gay for the editor.
To sum up Verday's take, it was announced Verday was going to be in the anthology, Verday wrote a love story between two boy fairies (the magical kind), editor asked Verday to change the story to a male/female story. Verday refused and decided she didn't even want her story in the book if the editor was that way.
Now, according to an update at the blog, the editor in question, Trisha Telep, responded by saying that the choice was all hers - she didn't think a male/male story would sell to the publisher, but the publisher is saying that they were perfectly ok with it. Verday is still refusing based on principle.
And I say, good for her.
In reality, we have no idea whose fault this is. It could be that what's the publisher told Telep to say, or that Telep is telling the truth. Or the publisher would have said exactly what Telep thought they would, but now they don't have to, so they're not going to say it publicly. They're not stupid.
Either way, it's still a case of homophobia - the fear of the gay. Telep was afraid the gay romance wouldn't belong in the anthology, which has a Young Adult angle, and that the publisher would reject the story because of it. In the end, Verday now has a story she can publish elsewhere. I suggest she go ahead and see if Kindle Singles is interested - it could be a nice match-up for the popular writer, and Amazon might be willing since she's already getting a bit of press over this.
In the end, for all the writers out there, I have one thing to say: you must only publish when your ethics say you should. Editors and publishers will make demands of you and your writing, and you must not allow them to change your intent or meaning. It's your name on the cover, not theirs. As an artist, you must have integrity. Readers can feel it when an author is being insincere in their work, and they frequently lose faith in the author because of it.
Before you see dollar signs, remember to ask yourself: is this really the kind of story I want to publish? If it's not, don't do it. If your writing is good enough, another publishing outlet will come along - one that won't jeopardize what you believe in.
Correction: Verday has informed me through Twitter that the boys aren't fairies, but that there is a magical fairy involved.